2023 mortgage market year in review

By: ameer@trustedteam.com

As we wrap up a year full of economic twists and turns—and interest rate ups and downs—we wanted to look back at some of the top mortgage-related stories that graced our pages in 2023.

Two rate holds by the Bank of Canada early in the year turned out to be a head-fake and prematurely led to market expectations that the rate-hike cycle was over. That in turn caused a short-lived run-up in home prices in the spring and and renewed upward inflationary pressure before the central bank delivered two more quarter-point rate hikes over the summer.

But markets and economists seem confident that 2023 was the Year of the Rate Peak, and that 2024 should herald in some welcome rate relief for borrowers with rate cuts expected by mid-year.

All of this was taking place against a backdrop of falling inflation. The year began with Canada’s headline Consumer Price Index inflation growing at a pace of 5.90%. As of November, that pace has slowed to 3.10%.

The average non-seasonally adjusted house price also reached a high of $729,044 in May before sliding back down to $646,134 as of November. That’s still up 5.5% from January, but down more than 20% from the all-time high reached in February 2022.

Here’s an overview of some of the year’s top mortgage stories, rate movements and mortgage-related stock performance.

Top mortgage stories of 2023

  • Mortgage credit growth plunged in 2023, falling by more than 25% compared to 2022. (Story)
  • Mortgage interest payments have continued to rise over the course of the year and are now nearly 90% higher compared to before the Bank of Canada’s rate hikes began. (Story)
  • There was a great deal of focus on the upcoming impact of higher interest rates on the estimated $600 billion worth of mortgages coming up for renewal in the next two years. The Bank of Canada said that alone was one of the key reasons it decided to leave interest rates on hold this fall. (Story)
  • Many variable-rate mortgage borrowers saw their amortizations soar thanks to rising interest rates, something the Bank of Canada said it was monitoring closely. (Story) But since the middle of the year, that trend has started to reverse with big banks like TD (Story) saying they’ve seen a drop in amortization lengths as borrowers increased payments or switched to fixed-rate mortgages.
  • Despite remaining near record lows for much of the year, early-stage delinquencies have now started to rise and are expected to keep trending upward. (Story)
  • Bond yields and in turn fixed mortgage rates see-sawed several times over the year, rising heading into the fall (Story), before plunging in the final months of the year. (Story)

Top deals & lender moves of 2023

  • BMO re-entered the mortgage broker channel (Story)
  • RBC closed its acquisition of HSBC Canada (Story)
  • Smith Financial closed its purchase of Home Capital Group (Story)
  • Scotiabank announced its plan to intentionally slow its mortgage portfolio growth (Story)
  • Filogix and Axiom signed 5-year agreement to enhance deal efficiency for brokers (Story)

Government and regulator news

  • OSFI ended up shelving some of its regulatory proposals for mortgage underwriting in response to stakeholder feedback (Story)
  • In June, OSFI rose the amount of capital banks must keep on hand in the event of defaults (Story)
  • On numerous occasions, OSFI voiced its concerns over fixed-payment variable-rate mortgages (Story)
  • It was thanks to an OSFI report that many in the industry learned no stress test is required on insured switches (Story)
  • The federal government made some concessions by announcing certain amendments to the foreign buyer ban (Story)

Rate Movements

The foundation for variable interest rates is the Bank of Canada’s overnight rate and prime rate, which both finished the year 75 basis points higher compared to where they started the year. That was on top of the 400 bps worth of rate hikes delivered in 2022.

Meanwhile, the most important benchmark for fixed-rate pricing—the 5-year government bond yield—ended the year down by 25 basis points to 3.17%. That was before it reached a peak of 4.42% in early October.

Indicator Year-end 2023 change
Bank of Canada overnight rate 5.00% +75 bps
Prime rate 7.20% +75 bps
Avg. 5-yr fixed rate on new insured mortgages1 5.54% +69 bps
Avg. variable rate on new insured mortgages1 7.06% +163 bps
5-year posted rate 7.04% +55 bps
Min. Qualifying Rate (MQR) 5.25% No change
5-yr government bond yield 3.17% -20 bps
1 Source: Bank of Canada via Statistics Canada, as of October 2023.

Stock moves

And finally, here’s a look at the performance of Canada’s big banks and public companies that make the majority of their revenue in the mortgage business.

Big 6 banks Share price 2023 change Dividend yield
Bank of Montreal $131.30 +5.5% 4.62%
CIBC $63.85 +15% 5.67%
National Bank $100.95 +10% 4.21%
Royal Bank of Canada $134.20 +4.8% 4.12%
Scotiabank $64.51 -1% 6.6%
TD Bank $85.58 -2% 4.79%
Mortgage companies Share price 2023 change Dividend yield
Atrium MIC $10.49 -0.2% 8.58%
Equitable Bank $87.20 +53% 1.85%
Firm Capital $10.87 +0.7% 8.72%
First National $38.53 +2.7% 6.38%
MCAN $15.85 +6.4% 9.65%
Timbercreek Capital $6.66 -8.6% 10.41%

As we turn the page on yet another tumultuous year headlined by rising interest rates and falling home prices, we wanted to take a look back at some of the top mortgage-related stories of 2022 and how mortgage rates fared.

Consumers grappled with rising prices in all nearly all aspects of the economy thanks to soaring inflation. But new homebuyers did get a reprieve when it came to Canadian real estate prices, which fell after reaching an all-time high earlier in the year. As of November, the average unadjusted price fell to $632,802, down 12% year-over-year and 22.5% below February’s price peak. 

On the other hand, borrowers had to deal with soaring interest rates, which slowed mortgage borrowing as non-mortgage debt grew.

Here’s an overview of some of the year’s top themes, rate movements and mortgage-related stock performance.


Top mortgage stories of 2022

  • Bank of Canada undergoes historic rate-tightening (Story)
  • Home prices ease from their peaks (Story)
  • Affordability becomes a big hurdle for new buyers (Story)
  • Controlling inflation became the Bank of Canada’s #1 priority (Story)
  • Tens of thousands of variable-rate borrowers reach their trigger points (Story)
  • Mortgage credit growth slows (Story)
  • CMHC updates its First-Time Home Buyer Incentive amid falling prices (Story)

Top deals & lender moves of 2022

  • RBC makes a $13.5-billion bid for HSBC Canada (Story)
  • First National co-founder offers to buy Home Capital (Story)
  • Rocket Mortgage comes to Canada (Story)
  • Equitable acquires Concentra Bank (Story)
  • TMG joins forces with Planipret, Quebec’s largest independent brokerage (Story)
  • National Bank’s broker push expands throughout Ontario (Story)

Rate Movements

The foundation for variable interest rates is the Bank of Canada’s overnight rate and prime rate, which both finished the year 400 basis points higher than where they began.

Meanwhile, the most important benchmark for fixed-rate pricingthe 5-year government bondended the year up over 200 basis points, which resulted in significantly higher fixed mortgage rates by year-end.

Indicator Year end 2022
change
BoC overnight rate 4.25% +400 bps
Prime rate 6.45% +400 bps
Avg. 5-yr fixed rate on new insured mortgages1 4.79% +227 bps
Avg. variable rate on new insured mortgages1 5.35% +388 bps
5-yr Posted Rate 6.49% +170 bps
Min. Qualifying Rate (MQR)
5.25% No change
5-yr government bond yield 3.42% +217 bps

Stock moves

And finally, here’s a look at the performance of Canada’s big banks and public companies that make the majority of their revenue in the mortgage business.


1 Source: Bank of Canada via Statistics Canada, as of October 2022.

Related post